The best New York City-inspired recipes (2024)

Cooking and baking evoke all sorts of memories, and we’re hoping that by making these New York City-inspired recipes, memories will come rushing back from your time in the Big Apple.

Related storyMartha Stewart's Fresh Quiche Recipe Is Perfect to Make For Any Occasion

We all have memories of NYC, whether we lived there, studied there or just passed through on a quick trip. NYC becomes part of you, and its recipes are here to bring you back.

1. Smoked salmon eggs Benedict recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (2)

Blog: Damn Delicious

A blend of two iconic New York favorites —smoked salmon and eggs Benedict —this smoked salmon eggs Benedict is an indulgent way to start the weekend.

2. Croissoughnuts recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (3)

Blog: Dinner with Julie

Croissoughnuts, also known as the famously trademarked “Cronuts” by Dominique Ansel, can be made at home with this recipe.

Related storyMartha Stewart's Fresh Quiche Recipe Is Perfect to Make For Any Occasion

3. New York-style bagels recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (5)

These are perfectly chewy, NYC-style bagels. Great rainy day afternoon project.

4. Black and white cookie recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (6)

Blog: The Novice Chef

Made with a vanilla cakelike cookie base,black and white cookies are the signature cookie of New York City, even appearing in episodes of Seinfeld.

5. Whitefish salad recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (7)

Blog: Tori Avey

Made from smoked whitefish, this whitefish salad can be found in most Jewish delis all over New York City.

6. Waldorf salad recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (8)

Blog: Country Cleaver

The Waldorf salad, said to be created between1893 and 1896 at the Waldorf Hotel in New York City, is typically dressed in mayonnaise. This version makes it a tad healthier by using nonfat Greek yogurt, a fantastic substitute.

7. NYC-style blueberry bagels recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (9)

Blog: French Press

Nothing says New York more than a bagel, and these NYC-style blueberry bagels are just the thing to bake on weekends when you’re craving a bite of the city. Add a smear of cream cheese, and you’re good to go.

8. S’mores baked Alaska recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (10)

Blog: Chocolate Moosey

Crazily enough, baked Alaska didn’t originate in Alaska, but at New York City’s Delmonico’s restaurant. We’re loving this version of a s’mores baked Alaska.

9. Mini cheesy pretzel dogs recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (11)

Blog: The Law Student’s Wife

There’s nothing more New Yorker than a pretzel, and these mini cheesy pretzel dogs are a great twist on a classic favorite.

10. Pastrami on rye recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (12)

Blog: Love & Olive Oil

What better sandwich to showcase New York than a pastrami on rye? Katz’s Deli has made it famous, and it’s even in movies like When Harry Met Sally.

11. Eggs Benedict recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (13)

Blog: Two Peas & Their Pod

Classic eggs Benedict, created at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel in New York, is always a great weekend brunch breakfast.

12. Traditional Jewish chopped liver recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (14)

Blog:Tori Avey

This traditional Jewish chopped liver makes for the perfect appetizer, and you can buy this in delis all around as well. It’s full of flavor and delicious fat, but well worth it.

13. New York-style coffee cake crumb muffins recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (15)

Blog: Table for Two

There’s nothing like these New York-style coffee cake crumb muffins to treat yourself.

14. New York cheesecake recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (16)

Blog: Urban Bakes

Creamy, luscious and oh so indulgent, the New York cheesecake is world famous and can be re-created at home for your cheesecake cravings.

15. Manhattan clam chowder recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (17)

Blog: Eat the Love

Some might find it a crime to add tomato to a clam chowder, but this Manhattan clam chowder is worth the crime. The writer says to think of it as a clam cioppino, and all will be OK.

16. Smoked salmon spread recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (18)

Blog: Foodie Crush

NYC delis are the place to be if you’re craving smoked salmon, and this smoked salmon spread is inspired by just that.

17. New York Times chocolate chip cookies recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (19)

Blog: Always Order Dessert

Made famous by the NYT, these New York Times chocolate chip cookies are seriously the perfect cookies. Bake them, and you’ll agree.

18. NY-style pizza recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (20)

Blog: Feeling Foodish

Not only is this NY-style pizza recipe spot on, but the 14 tips shared are there to help guide us into pizza heaven.

19. Mini New York cheesecakes recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (21)

Blog: Dessert for Two

When you don’t want to make an entire cheesecake, these mini New York cheesecakes come to the rescue, making only four small cakes.

20. Smoked salmon breakfast bagel recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (22)

Blog: Country Cleaver

Start your day with this gorgeous and tasty smoked salmon breakfast bagel.

21. Salt potatoes recipe

The best New York City-inspired recipes (23)

Blog: Foodie with Family

Nothing but simple new potatoes and tons of salt make these salt potatoes a sublime side dish or snack.

More on NYC recipes

Brown butter baked AlaskaOpen-faced apple butter pastrami sandwichesSmoked salmon crème fraîche tart

The best New York City-inspired recipes (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated:

Views: 5960

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.