| Icon | Name | Description | Tier | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Warden's Keys | The dull jangle of the keys evokes a furious memory within Caleb.
| A |   4.48 |
 | Modified Ammo Belt | An old ammo belt Caleb altered for his specialised weaponry.Still holds the fine red dirt of the Arizona Territory desert.
| A | 4.47 |
 | Tin Oil Can | A can holding a small amount of oil to reduce friction in machinery.Early models of the Speargun were notorious for jamming, and oil had to be readily available.
| A | 4.32 |
 | Iridescent Coin | A glass-like coin moulded from The Fog itself.A payment to the bounty hunter for the services rendered.
"Deals made in desperation are paid for in madness." | A | 4.23 |
 | Bayshore's Cigar | A quality cigar, plucked from the jacket of Caleb's boss while he wailed over the spear lodged in his abdomen.
"Do not point that thing at me, you slack-jawed imbecile." - Henry Bayshore | A | 4.15 |
 | Prison Chain | A thick, heavy chain that once held a steel ball and latched to Caleb's ankle.It has been re-purposed to hook onto a spear.
"Inmates working beyond the prison yard must be affixed with a steel ball of no less than 18 pounds." - Hellshire Penitentiary Guard Book | A |  4 |
 | Spit Polish Rag | A grimy piece of burlap.Spit and elbow grease was enough to wipe down the Speargun in the heat of a shootout.
| B | 3.94 |
 | Rusted Spike | A railroad spike that Caleb fastened to the front of the Speargun during a moment of morbid curiosity.The dull tip prevents it from cleanly piercing its target.
| B | 3.7 |
 | Barbed Wire | Pliable American-made steel lined with sharp barbs.Despite its simplicity, Caleb found it could be wrapped around a spear to increase its viciousness.
"There won't be nothing to fear soon. Till then, fear me." - Caleb Quinn | B | 3.55 |
 | Bayshore's Gold Tooth | A golden tooth torn from Henry Bayshore as he screamed for mercy, hours before he was finished off.
"Know your place, boy. Know you damn place." - Henry Bayshore | B | 3.24 |
| Icon | Name | Description | Tier | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Chewing Tobacco | A can of clipped and sweetened tobacco leaves lifted from a gutted body in Glenvale.Stimulates the nervous system.
| C | 2.71 |
 | Gold Creek Whiskey | Warm comfort in a bottle that quelled Caleb's anger and slowed his step.
"A smooth taste for the rugged frontier." - Gold Creek Advertisem*nt, 1876 | C | 2.58 |
 | Snake Oil | A tincture of oils and extracts purchased from a travelling salesman.Purported to cure all that ails you.
| C | 2.33 |
 | Hellshire Iron | The Hellshire Gang's branding iron.Despite folklore, it never made its mark on new initiates, instead having been used to brand particularly quarrelsome bounties.
"Hellshire Gang: Justice Seekers or Outlaws?" - Glenvale Gazette headline | C | 2.33 |
 | Wanted Poster | The bullet that ripped through Caleb's jaw during a frenzy shootout.It brings back burning desire for revenge.
"You'll be met with a fierce reckoning, swear it on my mum's grave." - Caleb Quinn | D | 2.15 |
 | Honey Locust Thorn | Angered with a bounty who fled twice before, Caleb twisted thorn branches onto a spear and let it loose.
| D | 2 |
 | Marshal's Badge | A silver badge taken from the corpse of a lawman in Arizona Territory who interfered with the Hellshire Gang's bounties.
"Get your prayers in, you'll be swinging by noon." - Caleb Quinn | D | 1.67 |
 | Poison Oak Leaves | An ordinary-looking plant, Caleb found out that spears coated in its oil cause unbearable blistering around wound.
| D | 1.63 |
 | Jaw Smasher | The bullet that ripped through Caleb's jaw during a frenzy shootout.It brings back burning desire for revenge.
"You called death to your door the instant you done me wrong." - Caleb Quinn | D | 1.5 |
 | Rickety Chain | Weak steel links first used on Caleb's prototype Speargun.Despite the chain's failings, it holds sentimental value.
| F | 1.42 |
